Debate: Should you cut out bad drywall or just patch it?

Ran into a corner that had water damage about 3 inches wide. Spent 4 hours trying to patch it with mesh tape and compound, and it still looked like garbage. Wondering if I should have just cut out a 2x2 foot section and started fresh. Which takes less time in the long run for you guys?

3 comments

Log in to join the discussion

Log In

3 Comments

rodriguez.diana4mo ago

Did you try using a hot mud for that first coat?

4

williamhill4mo ago

Hot mud saved my ass on a similar repair last month.

4

josephl674mo ago

Used to think patching was always faster but that one time I spent half a day fighting with a wet spot changed my mind. Cutting out a big square and throwing in new drywall takes maybe an hour tops and it looks right the first time.

0