Warning: I quit using a torque wrench on bundle ties and my inspector lost it
For 12 years I snugged every tube bundle tie by hand and never had a leak on a hydro. Last spring on a turnaround in Beaumont the QC guy flagged 14 of my ties as under torqued and I had to redo a whole pass. Now I use a torque wrench set at 45 ft-lbs and log every one in the book. Takes me about 20 extra minutes per bundle but I have not had a single call back in 8 jobs. The old hands on my crew say I am babying the iron, but I watched a hairline crack open on a unit in Port Arthur that we hand snugged. Anybody else get pushed into a torque spec, or am I the only one who caved?
Buddy of mine out in Baytown got the same speech from his QC guy last year and swore he would never go back. He told me the torque wrench saved his hide on a cold snap job when a bundle started weeping, turned out his hand snug was way off from the spec. Took him a minute to admit it but he logs every tie now too.