Switched from topping trees to crown reduction and my phone finally stopped ringing with complaints
I used to think topping was fine for controlling height on overgrown maples. Did it for years on residential jobs around Portland. Then a client called me back six months later saying the sprouts looked worse than the original problem, and honestly she was right. I read a study from Oregon State about how topping weakens branch attachments long term, and it finally clicked. Last spring I tried proper crown reduction on a big red oak instead, cutting back to lateral branches. The tree looks natural, the growth has been controlled, and the homeowner actually recommended me to three neighbors. Has anyone else had luck convincing customers to pay a bit more for the reduction work instead of the quick chop?