The 12 hour brisket number from a KCBS judge sheet floored me
I always figured the long overnight cook was just part of the deal, some kind of badge of honor. Then I sat in on a judging class over in Lexington and the guy running it pulled up a score sheet from a contest in Kansas City that showed a 12 hour brisket scoring lower than a 9 hour one from the same cook. He said the difference was moisture loss in the flat, plain and simple. I went home and ran my packer at 275 instead of 225 and pulled it at 9 hours, and the point was still plenty tender. I get why people love the all night ritual, but I think a lot of us are just cooking way longer than the meat needs. Has anyone else tracked their scores against cook time and seen the same thing?