Just realized the tack strip in that Dayton rental made my knee strips look stupid
I pulled up a 12 year old berber in a rental off Wayne Ave in Dayton last Tuesday and the tack strip under it was still biting hard, no soft spots, no rust, nothing. My own knee strips on a job in Cincinnati from 8 months back were already mush because I used the cheap box from the supply house instead of the good stuff. The difference was the nails, the old strip had 1 inch barbed nails every 4 inches and mine had 3/4 inch smooth ones that walked loose in the slab. I'm done going budget on strip, it's a $20 swing per room and it's the thing holding your whole stretch. What nail length are you guys running on concrete, because I think I've been wrong for a while here.
Doesn't it seem like the cheap stuff always fails right where it matters most? In my experience that's just how it goes with anything that gets hidden under something else, you never see the problem until it's way too late. I've noticed the same thing with paint and underlayment, the part nobody looks at is the part holding everything together. Your mileage may vary but I'd say go with the longest nail your slab will take without bottoming out, and the barbed ones make a real difference on concrete. Take this with a grain of salt since I'm no pro, but that old strip lasting 12 years says a lot about what the right nails can do.