20
Overheard a neighbor say 'raised beds are just expensive planters' and it stuck with me
I was out back last weekend messing with my drip irrigation (the cheap Orbit kit from Home Depot) when I heard my neighbor across the fence talking to his buddy. He said raised beds are just expensive planters and you're better off digging straight into the ground if your soil isn't pure clay. It got me thinking because I spent about $150 on wood and screws for two 4x8 beds last spring, and honestly my tomatoes did fine but my carrots were pretty stunted. This year I dug a small patch directly in the dirt behind my garage, mixed in some compost from the pile I've been turning since March, and my bean plants are way happier than the ones in the beds. The raised beds do keep the weeds down and look nice, but for root veggies I'm starting to think he had a point. Has anyone else found certain crops just do better in the ground no matter how good your bed setup is?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
ryan_ellis16d ago
Two 4x8 beds for $150? Man that stings. I spent $220 on cedar for two beds that size last year and the boards warped after one season. The comment about root veggies makes sense though. My beets were pathetic in the beds, all tops and no bulb. Ground soil just holds moisture better for stuff that needs to push down deep.
8
king.stella16d ago
Guess I should have saved the headache and just bought a really expensive bag of potting mix to dump straight on the ground instead. At least my wallet would have felt the same sting either way.
5
Honestly yeah, my carrots and radishes were always tiny in the beds but go nuts in the ground. Tbh I think the loose soil in raised beds dries out too fast for root crops to really dig in.
1