16
My brother's 'three gift rule' actually saved Christmas dinner last year
My older brother Dave kept telling me to set a hard limit on presents for the extended family. I thought he was being cheap. But last year we had 14 people in my aunt's tiny living room and the gift chaos almost started a fight. My cousin Karen spent $80 on a gift for someone who gave her a $10 candle. Dave's rule was simple: one thing you need, one thing to read, and one thing that's fun. After seeing that mess, I'm doing his system this year. Has anyone else had a gift exchange go sideways over money?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
faithwalker13d ago
Right on, that Karen vs. candle situation is exactly the kind of drama the three gift rule prevents. My extended family dodged a bullet last year by doing a "white elephant with a twist" where everyone brought a wrapped present under $15 and we drew numbers to steal from each other. The twist was that you couldn't keep a gift if you weren't willing to tell a funny story about why it represents you (my uncle had to explain his jar of pickled eggs, it was gold). That rule took all the money-angst out because nobody cared about the price tag, we were all just cracking up at the terrible gifts people brought. Plus it forces that one thing that's just fun from Dave's system, which is honestly the most important part.
7
jennysullivan13d ago
Wait, am I the only one who thinks the story rule might backfire? I get that it stopped the money drama at your party, but my family would weaponize those stories so fast. My aunt Kathy would tell a 20-minute tearjerker about how her $2 thrift store frame represents "the fragility of memories" just to guilt someone into letting her keep the good gift. And my cousin Mark would pick a weird gift on purpose just to be funny, which sounds great until he's done it three years in a row and everyone's sick of his jokes. I think Dave's rule feels safer because it gives clear categories without making anyone perform.
5
4